The First Time

Overview

The school musical West Side Story is readied for performance, with Artie as lead director. Finn meets with a football recruiter, whom Coach Beiste gains as an admirer. Kurt and Blaine reach a new, physical stage in their relationship, as do Rachel and Finn in theirs.

Guest Stars

Dot-Marie Jones

Sheldon Beiste

Grant Gustin

Sebastian Smythe

Dominic Barnes

Trent

Riker Lynch

Jeff

Damian McGinty

Rory Flanagan

Curt Mega

Nick

Titus Makin Jr.

David

Eric Bruskotter

Cooter Menkins